Skip to main content

​
What it is

Building Scotland: Conversations is an open interview series about the future of Scotland’s B2B tech ecosystem. Each episode brings together founders, operators, investors, and public-sector leaders to talk honestly about what is working, what is not, and what can improve. Every conversation ends with one clear, trackable pledge. The project sits in the context of James Varga’s active role in Scotland’s fintech and technology community and connects directly to the Ecosystem building in Scotland knowledge area.

​
Why it exists

Scotland has plenty of ecosystem conversation, plenty of programmes, and plenty of benchmarking reports. That pattern continues to produce the same frustration because it skips the first strategic step: Scotland has not clearly explained why it is building and funding a tech ecosystem. Building Scotland exists to surface that question, document lived experience, and create a persistent, accessible record of what founders, operators, and ecosystem builders actually see and propose.

​
What it produces

Conversations. Long-form interviews designed to surface what is true in practice, not what sounds good in theory. Published as articles on Substack and as podcast episodes on Label Sessions. Pledges. Every conversation ends with one clear pledge — something specific enough to track. Pledges are logged publicly on the ideas tracker. Articles and policy papers. Synthesised writing that draws on conversation themes to make specific proposals. Includes the Why Charter article, the Green AI Compute paper, and the Scotland in the AI Age policy whitepaper.

​
Conversations published

  1. Colin Carmichael — AI, momentum, and Scotland’s window. Pledge: establish a Scottish working group within the UK Business AI Alliance.
  2. Robert Gelb — founder dependency and market reality. Pledge: champion “do less but better” and founder autonomy over ecosystem dependency.
  3. Nick Sherrard — system accountability and conversion. Pledge: publish an open dataset on Scotland’s innovation spending.
  4. Andrew Williams — community, talent, and reconnection. Pledge: give time directly to founders and help replicate meetup formats across Scotland.
  5. Ross Laurie — a 20-year plan with economics. Pledge: red-team a 20-year ecosystem vision with written critique and alternatives.
  6. Chris Herd — maker or taker in the AI race. Energy as strategic advantage, mission-level framing.
  7. Nektarios Liolios — niche, motivation, and ecosystem design. The “why” question and ecosystem pillar alignment.
  8. Vicky Brock — Estonia, infrastructure, and inclusive entrepreneurship. Infrastructure-first thinking and inclusive language.

​
Articles and papers produced

​
Season 1 outputs

Season 1 produced three synthesised output documents alongside the conversation articles:
  1. The £230-per-head paradox — a data-led analysis showing Scotland spends comparably to Estonia on innovation but converts poorly. Proposes an Ecosystem Balance Sheet for tracking assets and liabilities.
  2. The 20-year plan framework — an operating system for long-term delivery, including the Ecosystem P&L model, rolling three-year plans, and six commitments for cross-party economic alignment.
  3. The national capability roadmap — six executable pillars with 90-day sprint definitions, including procurement hacks, Green AI Compute, the National Innovation Pathway, the Estonian Resolution Trigger, a public scoreboard, and Catalyst Pledges.
Season 1 also produced a roundtable format — structured working sessions where conversation participants and invited guests translate ideas into executable proposals. Roundtables produced a ranked list of top 10 ideas from across all conversations, with named owners and first-step commitments.

​
Recurring themes

Across all conversations, several themes repeat:
  • Focus over fragmentation. Scotland tries to support everything and converts poorly. Choosing a small number of priorities and executing well beats broad coverage.
  • The missing “why”. Scotland has not stated why it is investing in a tech ecosystem. Without that, objectives conflict and delivery fragments.
  • Spending does not equal outcomes. Per-capita innovation spending is high. Conversion to scaled companies is low. The system design, not the investment level, is the constraint.
  • Public sector as growth engine. Procurement is a lever, not just an administrative process. The state should be the earliest and best customer.
  • Community density has eroded. Post-COVID, Scotland’s founder community lost its physical rhythm. Reconnection is a prerequisite for serendipity and peer learning.
  • AI as the defining opportunity. The AI window is time-limited. Scotland’s energy, research, and data assets align with what the global AI economy now requires.

​
Status

Active. Eight conversations published. Articles and policy whitepaper published. Ideas tracker live at buildingscotland.net. Podcast available on Label Sessions.